A Real Alternative to the Bank Model: What MCA and Private Credit Do Differently
Where the new model beats traditional banks, where it falls short, and why banks are part of it.
6 min read
57%Applicants fully approved at small banks
60%Online-lender borrowers: cost higher than expected
0.1%Default rate on bank loans to non-bank financial firms, Q1 2026
28 / 37Bank / fund deals in our data
Sources are linked and numbered at the end. Figures from market-research firms and company press releases are estimates or claims by those parties, and we label each source by type. Our own counts come from the spreadsheet of announced MCA deals and are not a complete record of the market.
Is the MCA and private credit model a better way to finance small businesses than the traditional bank? The honest answer is that it is a different model that does some things better and some worse, and that banks are part of it. This article compares them on funding, underwriting, speed, cost and resilience, using Federal Reserve survey data, central bank research and our own deal records.
Two ways to fund a small business
Side by side
Dimension
Traditional bank
MCA and private credit model
Where the money comes from
Deposits and the bank's balance sheet
Private credit funds, banks and specialty lenders, through warehouse lines and forward-flow agreements[1, 2]
Underwriting
Credit history, financial statements, often collateral
Revenue and cash-flow data from bank, card or platform records
Speed
Often weeks
Often days
Repayment
Fixed instalments
Daily or weekly debits, or a share of sales
Who holds the risk
The bank, on its balance sheet
The funder, and often the investors who buy or finance the assets
Price
Lower on average
Higher on average. The survey below shows borrowers notice
Oversight
Bank capital and prudential rules
Lighter prudential rules. State disclosure laws are growing[3]
Where the new model fills a gap
What the data says
Share of applicants fully approved (%)
Small banks
57%
Large banks
43%
Online lenders
38%
Fed Small Business Credit Survey, 2025 survey year. Loans, lines of credit and merchant cash advances combined. Large-bank and online figures from the survey appendix.[4]
Share of applicants who went to online lenders (%)
The share of applicants seeking financing at online fintech lenders rose from 17% to 29% over five years.[4]
Large banks remain the most common first stop, but a growing share of businesses are applying elsewhere. Even counting partial approvals, a meaningful number of applicants do not get what they asked for from banks. The new model exists to serve some of those businesses.
The speed and data advantage
Why platforms can lend differently
1
Underwriting from live data
Fit
A payments or commerce platform can see sales as they happen. Parafin, for example, describes embedding financing within platforms like Amazon and DoorDash. That is a different information set from a tax return.[5]
2
Funding without holding the loan
Risk transfer
In a forward-flow agreement the investor buys loans after they are originated. Wayflyer's agreement with Fortress covers up to $1.5 billion over three years. The originator keeps originating, and the investor collects.[6, 7]
3
Capital that scales with the book
Capacity
Warehouse lines are sized to receivables. As a data-rich portfolio grows and performs, advance rates and facility sizes can grow too.
Among firms that borrowed. Only 4% of online-lender borrowers found costs lower than expected.[4]
Cost and clarity. The Federal Reserve reports high interest rates and unfavorable repayment terms as the most common challenges among online-lender applicants.[4]
Satisfaction. Credit union and bank applicants were more satisfied than online lender and finance company applicants.[4]
Funding stability. Banks fund with deposits. The new model depends on investors, and private credit vehicles have faced redemption pressure.[8]
Evolving rules. Eleven states now require cost disclosure for covered MCAs, and more may follow.[3]
The survey groups all online lenders, not only MCA funders, so it describes the wider category.
Banks are part of the model, not outside it
What the evidence shows
Banks do not originate private credit loans directly, but provide financing to private credit vehicles, according to Federal Reserve staff.[1]
Banks lend heavily to non-bank lenders. Business credit intermediaries, which include private credit funds and business development companies, are among the largest categories of bank loans to non-bank financial firms. Average default rates on such loans were about 0.1% in early 2026, compared with 1.4% for commercial and industrial loans.[9]
In our data, banks fund MCA companies directly. 28 of the 65 deals involve a bank or broker-dealer, from Goldman Sachs and Wells Fargo to Shawbrook and Barclays. The other 37 come from funds and specialty lenders.
Direct lending is still small next to banks overall. In a University of Chicago study of US middle-market companies (2022), 2.5% borrowed from direct lenders while 41.3% borrowed from banks. That is a different segment from small business, but it is a reminder that banks remain large.[10]
Debt rounds by lender type in our data
Funds and specialty lenders
37
Banks and broker-dealers
28
Our own classification. Counts are deals, not dollars.
A verdict
Complement, not replacement
Need
Likely better fit
Why
Cheapest long-term capital for a strong borrower
Bank
Lower average cost and higher satisfaction in the survey
Fast capital for a seasonal or short-term need
MCA or platform lender
Speed and data-based decisions
Business with a thin credit file but strong sales
MCA or platform lender
Underwriting uses sales data
Funding a lender's own receivables book at scale
Private credit or bank warehouse line
Short assets, data-rich servicing, forward-flow options
Stable funding through a downturn
Bank, with caution
Deposit funding, but banks also tighten credit
Our view. The MCA and private credit model is a real alternative for businesses and lenders that banks serve poorly or slowly. It is not a replacement. The strongest lenders will use both: private credit for scale and speed, and banks for stable, lower-cost capital and for funding the funders.
What it takes to be a credible alternative
Six tests
Clear total cost for the customer, in dollars and, where required, as an estimated APR
Compliance with state disclosure and registration rules
Underwriting that performs in static-pool data, not just in a pitch
More than one funder, so one pulled line does not stop originations
Facility terms with headroom and tiers before default
Fair collections and a path for customers who fall behind
Takeaways
It is a different model, not a better or worse one. It wins on speed and data fit, and loses on average cost and satisfaction.
Banks are inside the model. They finance private credit vehicles and fund MCA companies directly.
The gap is real. A rising share of applicants uses online lenders.
Funding stability is the model's weak point. It relies on investors, not deposits.
Credibility comes from transparency: cost, compliance, data and diversified funding.